In Lies of P, honesty and deception play pivotal roles, affecting the game's progression and outcomes. Throughout the game, you'll face choices between telling the truth or lying, each with its consequences. This guide outlines all the significant Truth and Lie choices you'll encounter.

Table of Contents

1. Woman in the Window (Elysion Boulevard) 
2. Alidoro (St. Frangelico Chapel Library) 
3. Julian the Gentleman (Rosa Isabelle Street Culvert) 
4. Lady Antonia (Hotel Krat)
5. Polendina (Hotel Krat)
6. Simon Manus (Grand Exhibition)
7. Eugenie and Alidoro, Part 1 (Hotel Krat and Barren Swamp)
8. Belle (Hotel Krat and Ruined Krat Station)
9. Eugenie and Alidoro, Part 2 (Hotel Krat and Relic of Trismegistus)
10. Venigni (Hotel Krat and Relic of Trismegistus)
11. Arlecchino (Relic of Trismegistus and Arche Abbey Outer Wall)
12. Sophia (Ascension Bridge)
13. Geppetto (Arche Abbey Upper Part)
14. Simon Manus (Cradle of the Gods)
15. Simon and Sophia (Final Encounter)

Impact of Telling the Truth or a Lie

Your decisions in Lies of P significantly influence the story, leading to various outcomes and rewards:

Multiple Endings: Lies of P offers three distinct endings, each determined by your predominant choices of honesty or deceit. While you don't need an all-truth or all-lie playthrough, a consistent approach is recommended to achieve your desired ending. Your choices will affect P's perception and key attributes.

The Golden Lie Secret Weapon: By consistently choosing to lie, you can unlock the unique "Golden Lie" secret weapon. Displaying this artifact within Hotel Krat triggers its transformation, offering a special post-campaign weapon.

Record Rewards: Your choices affect the records you collect in the game, providing valuable insights into the lore and character backgrounds.

List of All Truth or Lie Choices

Here's a breakdown of the 15 Truth or Lie encounters in Lies of P, along with their locations and consequences:

1. Woman in the Window (Elysion Boulevard)

• Description: Encountering a woman who believes her baby is adorable.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "That's just a puppet."
  • Lie: "That's a cute baby."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive a Vivid Ergo Fragment and Feel.
  • Lie: Pinocchio's humanity grows.

2. Alidoro (St. Frangelico Chapel Library)

• Description: Meeting Alidoro and his inquiry about a safe area.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "Hotel Krat."
  • Lie: "Venigni Works."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Alidoro becomes a vendor in Hotel Krat.
  • Lie: Alidoro becomes a vendor at Venigni Works Workshop Union.

3. Julian the Gentleman (Rosa Isabelle Street Culvert)

• Description: Assisting Julian in recovering his deceased wife's belongings.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "I've never seen that happen before."
  • Lie: "I saw her message saying she loves you."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive a Radiant Ergo Fragment.
  • Lie: Obtain Julian's Wedding Ring and a Sad Gesture.

4. Lady Antonia (Hotel Krat)

• Description: Speaking with Lady Antonia after defeating the King of Puppets boss in the Opera House.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "There is nothing left."
  • Lie: "Of course."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: No items received.
  • Lie: Points with Lady Antonia for good manners (no objects).

5. Polendina (Hotel Krat)

• Description: Conversing with Polendina in the garden leading to City Hall about puppet-human love.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "I have."
  • Lie: "There's no such puppet."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Polendina appears in Hotel Krat as a vendor.
  • Lie: Polendina appears at the Venigni Works Workshop Union.

6. Simon Manus (Grand Exhibition)

• Description: Engaging with Simon Manus after defeating Champion Victor regarding the Petrification Disease and the "cure."
• Choices:
  • Truth: "Hope for a cure."
  • Lie: "Monsters."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive the Saintess of Mercy Statue Gallery Key.
  • Lie: Still receive the Saintess of Mercy Statue Gallery Key.

7. Eugenie and Alidoro, Part 1 (Hotel Krat and Barren Swamp)

• Description: Receiving Four-Fingered Gloves from Eugenie in Hotel Krat and giving them to Alidoro in the Barren Swamp.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "He was angry. He said the gloves were rubbish."
  • Lie: "He was happy."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive an Electric Blitz Abrasive.
  • Lie: Receive a Fire Abrasive.

8. Belle (Hotel Krat and Ruined Krat Station)

• Description: Assisting Belle in Hotel Krat and later finding her partner, Atkinson, in the Ruined Krat Station.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "He became a monster."
  • Lie: "He was killed in action fighting a puppet."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive an Electric Blitz Canister and the Why expression.
  • Lie: Receive an Electric Blitz Canister and the Why expression.

9. Eugenie and Alidoro, Part 2 (Hotel Krat and Relic of Trismegistus)

• Description: After defeating the Black Rabbit Brotherhood 2.0, confronting Alidoro and Eugenie in Hotel Krat.
• Choices:
  • Truth (Option 1): "The fake one murdered the real Alidoro."
  • Truth (Option 2): "He was Eugenie's older brother."
  • Lie: "I think he's just a talented Stalker."
• Outcome:
  • Truth (Option 1): Alidoro reveals his true identity, further investigating his story.
  • Truth (Option 2): Eugenie discovers her brother's fate, exploring his background.
  • Lie: Alidoro remains deceived.

10. Venigni (Hotel Krat and Relic of Trismegistus)

• Description: Speak with Venigni in Hotel Krat after clearing the Black Rabbit Brotherhood 2.0 encounter.

• Choices:
  • Truth: "Geppetto caused the puppet frenzy."
  • Lie: "I couldn't hear."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: No rewards.
  • Lie: No rewards.

11. Arlecchino (Relic of Trismegistus and Arche Abbey Outer Wall)

• Description: Encountering a payphone in the Relic of Trismegistus and later finding Arlecchino in chains in the Arche Abbey Outer Wall.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "Puppet."
  • Lie: "Human."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Receive the King of Riddles' Surprise Box, leading to the Chosen One's Trinity Key.
  • Lie: Receive the King of Riddles' Surprise Box, leading to the Chosen One's Trinity Key.

12. Sophia (Ascension Bridge)

• Description: Discovering Sophia's true form on the Ascension Bridge after defeating Laxasia the Complete.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "Let her live."
  • Lie: "Give her peace."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Sophia continues to exist in her current state.
  • Lie: Sophia receives peace, ending her suffering.

13. Geppetto (Arche Abbey Upper Part)

• Description: Encountering Geppetto in his cell in the Arche Abbey Upper Part and discussing trust.
• Choices:
  • Truth: "No."
  • Lie: "Yes."
• Outcome:
  • Truth: Geppetto expresses disappointment but remains resolved.
  • Lie: Geppetto gains confidence while maintaining his resolve.

14. Simon Manus (Cradle of the Gods)

• Description: Speaking with Simon Manus after defeating him in the Cradle of the Gods and discussing the fate of Sophia.
• Choices:
  • Truth (if you gave her peace): "I gave her peace."
  • Truth (if you let her live): "I liberated her from Arche Abbey."
  • Lie (if you gave her peace): "I liberated her from Arche Abbey."
  • Lie (if you let her live): "I gave her peace."
• Outcome:
  • Truth (if you gave her peace): Simon acknowledges your choice.
  • Truth (if you let her live): Simon questions your choice.
  • Lie (if you gave her peace): Simon questions your choice.
  • Lie (if you let her live): Simon respects your decision.

15. Simon and Sophia (Final Encounter)

• Description: A final conversation with Simon about the fate of Sophia, based on your previous choices.
• Choices:
  • Truth (if you gave her peace): "I gave her peace."
  • Truth (if you let her live): "I gave her peace."
  • Lie (if you gave her peace): "I liberated her from Arche Abbey."
  • Lie (if you let her live): "I liberated her from Arche Abbey."
• Outcome:
  • Truth (if you gave her peace): Simon acknowledges your choice.
  • Truth (if you let her live): Simon acknowledges your choice.
  • Lie (if you gave her peace): Simon challenges your statement.
  • Lie (if you let her live): Simon respects your decision.

Remember, you don't need to exclusively choose truth or lies, but consistency is key to achieving your desired outcomes in Lies of P.

That is all you need to know about truths and lies in Lies of P. Make sure to check out our other Lies of P guides below:

How to Respec - Special Weapons Locations - Legion Caliber Locations - Quartz Locations - Hermit's Cave -Cryptic Vessel Locations -  Phone Riddles - Upgrade Weapons - Every Ending